Round or Rectangle

Just a quick little post to get your opinions on the window in the dormer above the door.

I found my round and rectangle windows and taped each of them up.  The round one I put in two different places since it's a small window.

I debated for a while about the diamond vs square window but neither of them looked right to me.  While the diamond echoed the lines of the dormer roof, it looked too modern.  And it was really big.

The square matched the lines of the other windows but it was just too big for the front wall I think.

So here's the rectangle.

They're just phone pictures so they're not that great.  But I like how the rectangle looks.  I could even move it up a bit more so it's about three feet from the floor and it still wouldn't crowd the roof too much.

It's narrow enough for the dormer and it has the advantage of matching the shape of the other windows on the main body of the cottage.

I'll admit, after seeing it I almost didn't bother to try out the round window.  But I figured why not since I'd dug it out to test.

Here it is a bit higher on the dormer.

It's pretty but it's such a small window I'm not sure it works.

Here it is a bit lower.

Much as I like the round window, it still feels a little too modern and it's very small.  So I'm leaning towards the rectangle window.

What do all of you think?